
The preliminary assessment is the first decision the Health and Disability Commissioner (HDC) makes on a complaint. For healthcare professionals in New Zealand it decides which path the complaint takes: no further action, a referral to someone else, or a formal investigation. This guide explains what the Commissioner looks at, the options the law gives, what you are asked to send at this stage and when your Council or Board is told.
If a complaint has reached you, Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, self-paced, with a dated certificate on completion.
What is the HDC preliminary assessment?
Section 33 of the Health and Disability Commissioner Act 1994 says that, as soon as reasonably practicable after receiving a complaint, the Commissioner must make a preliminary assessment of it. The purpose is to decide which course of action to take. The Commissioner must then promptly tell both the complainant and the provider what the preliminary assessment is. The assessment can be revised later, and the parties are told again if it changes.
On its page for providers, the HDC says its Complaints Assessment Team reads and reviews the complaint and tells you about it. The Commissioner or a Deputy Commissioner decides the outcome, and you receive a written explanation of it.
What options does the Commissioner have?
Section 33(1) of the Act lists the courses of action open to the Commissioner. One or more can be chosen:
- Refer the complaint to an agency or person under section 34 or section 36 (see below).
- Refer the complaint to an advocate from the Nationwide Health and Disability Advocacy Service, to help resolve it by agreement.
- Call a conference of the parties.
- Investigate the complaint.
- Take no action on the complaint.
Section 34(1) sets out who a complaint can be referred to, in whole or in part: the responsible authority, where the competence, fitness to practise or conduct of a practitioner may be in doubt; ACC, where the person may be entitled to cover; the Director-General of Health, where failures in a provider's systems may harm the public; and the provider itself, where the complaint does not raise questions about public health or safety and the provider can resolve it. Section 36 covers referral to the Human Rights Commission, the Ombudsman or the Privacy Commissioner.
Section 38 lets the Commissioner decide to take no action, or no further action, where action is unnecessary or inappropriate. The factors in the Act include the time that has passed since the events, whether the matter is trivial, whether the complaint was made in good faith, the wishes of the person affected, and whether another adequate remedy or right of appeal exists.
How do HDC complaints end? The latest figures
The HDC Annual Report 2025 (year to 30 June 2025) gives the scale of the work:
- 3,477 complaints received and 4,406 complaints closed in 2024/25;
- around 68% of complaints closed were closed through early resolution pathways;
- around 7–8% of complaints received proceed to a formal investigation;
- around 70% of complaints received are resolved within six months.
With around two in three closed complaints ending through early resolution, what you send at the assessment stage carries weight.
What are you asked to do at this stage?
The HDC says that at the assessment stage it will ask you to tell your side of the story and will request the clinical notes. It may also seek advice from a peer or an expert in your field before deciding. It says a complaint can be closed without a formal investigation where it finds that the care was largely appropriate.
- Tell your indemnity insurer or professional body as soon as the letter arrives, and agree the response with them before you send it.
- Read the complaint for the specific concerns and answer each one, in the order raised.
- Send complete records. Never change or delete an existing entry or back-date a note; if something needs correcting, add a new dated note that shows the change, and explain the rest in the response.
- Explain your reasoning at the time, using the records, and say plainly where something could have gone better.
- Say what you have done since, with dates: changes to your practice, a reflection, a course completed.
The steps for writing the reply itself are in our guide on what to do after an HDC complaint.
When does the HDC tell your Council or Board?
The Act sets out three points at which your responsible authority can hear from the Commissioner:
- Referral. Under section 34(1)(a) the Commissioner can refer a complaint to the authority where your competence, fitness to practise or conduct may be in doubt.
- Risk of harm. Under section 39(1), if the Commissioner believes your practice may pose a risk of harm to the public, the Commissioner must promptly notify the authority.
- Investigation. Under section 42(1), if an investigation directly concerns a practitioner, the Commissioner must promptly give notice of it to the authority.
What the authority does next is explained in what happens after an HDC complaint, and the investigation route in an HDC breach finding and the Director of Proceedings.
What comes after the preliminary assessment?
If the complaint is closed, you receive the decision in writing, which can include comments or recommendations, such as an apology to the complainant. If it is referred to an advocate, the advocate works with the complainant and you to resolve it. If the Commissioner opens an investigation, you receive written notice and the HDC asks for a written response within 15 days; the process ends in an opinion on whether the Code of Rights was breached.
Where remediation and CPD fit
Where the complaint is about how care was explained or delivered, a short remediation plan sent with your response shows what you have changed. Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally covers the response itself, and Effective Communication for Healthcare Professionals covers the communication a complaint can turn on. Our guide to insight, reflection and a remediation plan shows how a dated certificate fits. Without a complaint, each course gives 2 CPD hours for your CPD record. Each is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10).
Sources and further reading
- Health and Disability Commissioner: the complaint sections of the Act (ss 33–42): preliminary assessment, referral, no action and notice to authorities.
- Health and Disability Commissioner: what if a complaint is made about me?: the assessment stage as the HDC describes it to providers.
- Health and Disability Commissioner: the complaint process: outcomes and timeframes.
- Health and Disability Commissioner: Annual Report 2025: complaint figures for 2024/25.
This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a Council or Board complaint? A course matched to the concern, from our online courses, is written for health practitioners and follows your Council or Board's code of conduct; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my Council or Board investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which a Professional Conduct Committee and your Council or Board look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Council, Board or Health and Disability Commissioner — or before a Professional Conduct Committee, the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal or a competence review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
What is an HDC preliminary assessment?
For healthcare professionals in New Zealand, it is the first decision the Health and Disability Commissioner makes on a complaint. Under section 33 of the Health and Disability Commissioner Act 1994, the Commissioner decides whether to take no action, refer the complaint, call a conference or investigate.
Will I be told about the complaint?
Yes. The Act requires the Commissioner to promptly tell both the complainant and the provider the preliminary assessment, and the HDC says it tells healthcare professionals in New Zealand about a complaint and asks for their side and their clinical notes.
Can I respond before a decision is made?
Yes. The HDC asks healthcare professionals in New Zealand for a response and records at the assessment stage, and says you will have the chance to respond to any adverse comments or recommendations about you before the decision is final.
Does the HDC always tell my Council or Board?
Not in every case. For healthcare professionals in New Zealand, the Act lets the Commissioner refer a complaint to the responsible authority where competence, fitness to practise or conduct may be in doubt, and requires notice to the authority where practice may pose a risk of harm or an investigation directly concerns a practitioner.
Is there a course for an HDC complaint or for CPD?
Yes. Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, self-paced, with a dated certificate for a remediation plan after an HDC complaint, or for the CPD record of healthcare professionals in New Zealand.
