
A Medical Council NZ ethical boundaries course is for doctors in New Zealand where a concern turns on a dual relationship: a patient who is also a relative, a friend, a business contact or an employee, or a colleague whom the doctor also treats, supervises or is close to. The Medical Council of New Zealand's standards ask you to recognise the second relationship, declare it where it could affect your judgement, and keep it from shaping the care or the decision.
What a dual relationship looks like in medical practice
The Council's rules on second relationships sit in several of its documents:
- Treating someone close to you. Other than in exceptional circumstances, do not provide medical care to yourself or to anyone you have a close personal relationship with (Good medical practice, paragraph 11).
- Certifying for a relative. Never issue a certificate for yourself or someone you are closely related to (statement on medical certification, paragraph 12).
- Acting for a patient. Acting as a patient's representative or under their enduring power of attorney is unwise, because it can be seen as undue influence (professional boundaries statement, paragraph 12).
- A relationship with a patient's family member. An intimate relationship is unethical if it could affect the patient's care, or if you used power, knowledge or influence gained through the patient to start or keep it (sexual boundaries statement, paragraph 43).
- A financial interest in the care. Disclose to the patient any interest in a facility you refer to, make clear the choice is theirs, and record the disclosure (commercial organisations statement, paragraphs 17 and 20).
- A colleague you supervise. A supervisor must deal with, and report where serious, concerns about a supervisee's performance or behaviour (unprofessional behaviour statement, paragraph 16), which a personal tie makes harder to do fairly.
The Council's test: could the second relationship affect your judgement?
The commercial organisations statement defines a conflict of interest to include non-financial interests such as close relationships, and says a perceived conflict can do as much harm as a real one. Your decisions must be free from actual or perceived bias (paragraph 5). If you are unsure, act as though a conflict exists (paragraph 8), disclose it fully and record it (paragraph 10). Good medical practice paragraph 58 adds that you declare a conflict and be prepared to withdraw from decisions it affects.
The guide to dual relationships in small communities covers the cases where a second relationship cannot be avoided.
Power in relationships with patients and with colleagues
With a patient, the professional boundaries statement starts from the doctor's greater power (paragraph 1). With a colleague, the unprofessional behaviour statement shows how a difference in position affects people: colleagues may avoid a doctor or hold back from asking for help (paragraph 9), and students and junior doctors may be reluctant to ask for feedback (paragraph 10). Good medical practice paragraph 41 says not to bully or harass colleagues. In a dual relationship with a junior colleague, a supervisee or a member of your staff, your response needs to answer whether your position made it harder for them to say no.
How a dual relationship concern reaches the Council and what follows
A patient may complain to the HDC, which can send the complaint on to the Council as the registration authority; Right 2 of the Code of Rights includes freedom from exploitation. Anyone else can notify the Council directly. The Council asks for your response and its triage team decides the next step. If a Professional Conduct Committee is appointed, its outcomes include asking the Council to review your scope of practice, a determination that the notification go to conciliation, and a charge before the Tribunal. The guide to a boundary crossing and a boundary violation helps you place the relationship.
What the ethical boundaries course covers
Ten sections cover ethical boundaries with patients and with colleagues, the part power plays in each, and what the Medical Council and the other authorities expect. The risks covered are sexual, financial, emotional, collegial and digital, with weak and strong responses compared. Later sections cover remediation through CPD, supervision and reflection, and presenting boundary awareness at a hearing.
When a different course fits better
If the concern is a gift, money, messages or a sexual boundary with a patient, the Medical Council NZ boundaries course is closer to it. If treating a relative or a colleague led to a question about who saw their records, the Medical Council NZ confidentiality course fits.
Sources and further reading
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Good medical practice (1 November 2021): paragraphs 11, 41 and 58.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Statement on medical certification (18 August 2023): paragraph 12 on certifying for those close to you.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Professional boundaries in the doctor-patient relationship (1 November 2018): power imbalance and acting as a patient's representative.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Sexual boundaries in the doctor-patient relationship (1 November 2018): relationships with a patient's family member.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Doctors and health-related commercial organisations (1 February 2023): non-financial conflicts of interest, disclosure and records.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Statement on unprofessional behaviour (1 August 2020): effects of position on colleagues, and supervisors' duties.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Conduct and competence concerns: notifications and the triage stage.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Professional Conduct Committee: the outcomes a Professional Conduct Committee can reach.
- Health and Disability Commissioner: About the complaint process: how the HDC handles and refers a complaint.
- Health and Disability Commissioner: Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights: Right 2.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Recertification requirements for doctors practising in the General scope of practice: peer review and collegial meetings in Inpractice.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a Council or Board complaint about ethical boundaries? Our ethical boundaries course is written for health practitioners and follows your Council or Board's code of conduct; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my Council or Board investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which a Professional Conduct Committee and your Council or Board look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Council, Board or Health and Disability Commissioner — or before a Professional Conduct Committee, the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal or a competence review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
Is there an ethical boundaries course for doctors?
Yes. Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues is an online CPD course for doctors in New Zealand facing a complaint or Medical Council notification about a dual relationship with a patient or a colleague. It is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10), takes 2 CPD hours and ends with a dated certificate.
Can I treat a family member or a friend?
Good medical practice says that, other than in exceptional circumstances, you should not provide medical care to anyone you have a close personal relationship with. The statement on medical certification also says never to certify for someone closely related to you. If exceptional circumstances arose, record what they were and why you acted.
Is a relationship with a colleague a matter for the Medical Council?
It can be, where it affects patient care or where your position over the colleague is part of the concern. Good medical practice says not to bully or harass colleagues, and the Council's statement on unprofessional behaviour sets out a supervisor's duties. Anyone can notify the Council.
What can a Professional Conduct Committee decide about a dual relationship?
It can determine that no further steps be taken, that the notification go to conciliation, or that a charge be laid before the Tribunal. It can also ask the Council to review your competence, fitness or scope of practice, or to counsel you. You do not have to meet the Committee, but take advice before you decide.
Does the ethical boundaries course count as CPD?
Yes. It gives 2 CPD hours and a dated certificate. Inpractice also asks for 10 hours of peer review and four collegial meetings each 12 months, and a dual relationship you are managing is a fitting subject to take to them, with a dated note of the advice you received.
