
A recommendation that you be counselled is one of the outcomes a Professional Conduct Committee (PCC) can reach under section 80 of the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003 (the HPCA Act). It goes to your Council or Board, which must consider it promptly and decide what you are required to do. Depending on the authority, counselling means counselling by an experienced practitioner the authority arranges, a letter of counsel, or counselling that can include supervision or mentorship. Read what you receive in full, do what it asks in the time it gives, and keep it with your records. Then write a reflection and show what you have changed. A recommendation to counsel is not a charge before the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, and it carries none of the Tribunal's penalties.
To start on remediation now, Ensuring No Repeat of Misconduct or Mistake covers how to work out what went wrong and show the steps that stop it happening again. It is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, self-paced, with a dated certificate on completion.
What a PCC can recommend and determine
Section 80 of the Act gives a PCC two kinds of outcome. Recommendations go to the Council or Board, and the PCC can make one or more. A determination is the PCC's own decision on what happens to the matter, and it makes one.
- Recommendations. That the authority review your competence; review your fitness to practise; review your scope of practice; refer the subject matter to the police; or counsel you.
- Determinations. That no further steps be taken; that a charge be brought before the Tribunal; or, for a complaint, that it be submitted to conciliation.
The Act's word is "counsel". Each authority describes what that means for its own practitioners, and the descriptions differ, as set out below. Read the determination in your letter as well as the recommendation: the Medical Council says it cannot review or change determinations made by a PCC, so the determination stands as written. The guide to how a Professional Conduct Committee process runs covers the investigation that came before it.
Your right to be heard first
Before a PCC makes a recommendation or a determination, the Act gives you a reasonable opportunity to make written submissions and to be heard. If you have been told the PCC is about to decide, this is the point to put your account, your reflection and any remediation you have already completed in front of it.
Speak to your indemnity insurer or professional association (for doctors the Medical Protection Society, for nurses NZNO, for midwives NZCOM) or a lawyer before you send anything. A submission that shows insight, with evidence of change already made, gives the PCC something specific to weigh before it decides on its recommendations and its determination.
What happens once the recommendation reaches your Council or Board
- The authority considers it. Section 81 of the Act says the Council or Board must promptly consider a PCC's recommendation.
- The authority decides what counselling will involve. Each authority has its own approach, set out in the next section.
- You are told what is required. The Psychologists Board's PCC guidelines, for example, say its Secretariat then informs the psychologist what is required of them. Read what you receive in full and note each step and each date.
- You take part, or you receive the letter. Attend the counselling arranged for you, or read the letter of counsel and do what it asks, in the time it gives.
- You keep it with your records. File the letter, the dates of any sessions and your own notes with the PCC's report and your submissions.
- You show the change. Write a reflection and keep a remediation plan with dated evidence, ready for any later request.
What counselling looks like at different authorities
- Medical Council. The Council's options sheet says a PCC recommendation to counsel "can include providing further education, supervision and/or mentorship".
- Nursing Council. The Council says a PCC can recommend sending a letter of counsel to the nurse, which it also calls an education letter.
- Pharmacy Council. Where a PCC has concerns about conduct that do not warrant a charge, it may recommend counselling. The Council then arranges for an experienced pharmacist, and sometimes a counselling psychologist, to counsel the pharmacist, so that relevant professional standards are understood and applied in future.
- Psychologists Board. A PCC can recommend that the Board counsel the psychologist, and the Secretariat then tells the psychologist what is required. Separately, the Board's committee can close a complaint with an advisory letter, and may ask the psychologist for a letter of reflection.
Other Councils and Boards apply the same section of the Act in their own way. If your letter does not say what counselling involves, who provides it or by when, ask the Council or Board in writing, through your adviser.
What to do with a letter of counsel
- Read it twice. Note each concern it names and each step it asks of you, with any dates.
- Act on it. Do what it asks, in the time it gives, with whoever it names. If it asks you to meet someone, attend; if it asks you to reply, reply by the date.
- Keep it with your records. File it with the PCC's report and your submissions, so that you can refer to it accurately if another concern is raised or the authority asks about it.
- Reflect in writing. Write what happened, why, which standard it fell short of, what you understand now and what you have changed. The guide to showing insight, reflection and a remediation plan sets out the order.
- Show the change. Keep a remediation plan with dated evidence: notes from a supervisor or mentor, an audit, a changed process, a course certificate. The Pharmacy Council, for example, looks in some complaints for evidence that the pharmacist has assessed the incident in detail, such as through a root-cause analysis, and has identified the lessons.
Have your adviser read the reflection before it goes anywhere, and do not alter a clinical record.
How this differs from a charge before the Tribunal
A determination that a charge be brought sends the matter to the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. Under section 101 of the Act the Tribunal can cancel your registration, suspend you for up to three years, order you to practise under conditions for up to three years after you resume, censure you, fine you up to $30,000 and order you to pay costs. A recommendation to counsel carries none of these. It is a step the authority takes with you, not a penalty imposed after a hearing.
If your letter shows a charge as the PCC's determination, the guide to a Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal hearing explains what follows. In published decisions the Tribunal has said it considers the rehabilitation of health practitioners and the least restrictive penalty, and in one decision it gave credit for a course on the Nursing Council's Code of Conduct, counselling and an apology.
Where remediation courses fit
A course from this site is not a replacement for counselling the authority arranges or for anything a letter of counsel asks of you. It gives you the standards and a structure to write from. Before a PCC decides, a completed course is evidence that remediation is under way. After a recommendation to counsel, it is material for the discussion in counselling, your reflection and your remediation plan.
Ensuring No Repeat of Misconduct or Mistake covers how to show that a change has held. Reflection for Fitness to Practise covers how to write the reflection a letter of counsel calls for. Rebuilding Trust of Patients, the Public and the Regulator is written for the stage after a conduct concern. Each course is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10), takes 2 CPD hours, is self-paced with immediate access, and ends with a dated certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses that you can put in your remediation plan.
If the authority's response also includes a competence review or a programme, the guide to being told to complete a course or competence programme covers the orders that can follow. The remediation courses for every Council and Board are on the hub page, and the Council and Board investigation process explained shows where a PCC sits among the other stages.
Sources and further reading
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Professional Conduct Committee: what a PCC can recommend and determine for a doctor.
- Nursing Council of New Zealand: fitness to practise: PCC recommendations, including a letter of counsel.
- Pharmacy Council of New Zealand: competence and conduct committees: how counselling is arranged after a PCC recommendation.
- New Zealand Psychologists Board: PCC Guidelines for Practitioners: the PCC process and what follows a recommendation.
This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub. See also the Professional Boundaries hub.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a Council or Board complaint? A course matched to the concern, from our online courses, is written for health practitioners and follows your Council or Board's code of conduct; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my Council or Board investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which a Professional Conduct Committee and your Council or Board look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Council, Board or Health and Disability Commissioner — or before a Professional Conduct Committee, the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal or a competence review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
Is a letter of counsel a disciplinary finding?
It is not a Tribunal finding. A letter of counsel follows a recommendation a Professional Conduct Committee makes to your Council or Board under section 80 of the Act, not a charge heard by the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, and it carries none of the Tribunal's penalties. It is still the authority's response to a concern about your conduct, so read it with care, do what it asks and keep it with your records.
Can I challenge a PCC's recommendation to counsel?
Your opportunity to be heard comes before the PCC decides: the Act gives you a reasonable opportunity to make written submissions and to be heard. The Medical Council says it cannot review or change determinations made by a PCC. If you believe the process was unfair, speak to your indemnity insurer, professional association or a lawyer about the options open to you, and do not write to the authority about it without their advice.
Who provides the counselling?
It depends on the authority. The Pharmacy Council arranges an experienced pharmacist, and sometimes a counselling psychologist, to counsel the pharmacist. The Nursing Council can send the nurse a letter of counsel. The Medical Council says counselling can include supervision or mentorship, and the Psychologists Board counsels the psychologist after the PCC's recommendation. If your letter does not say who will counsel you, or when, ask the Council or Board in writing, through your adviser.
Should I write a reflection after counselling?
Yes. A written reflection shows that you have understood the concern and what you have changed as a result. Set out what happened, why, which standard it fell short of, what you understand now and what you do differently. The Psychologists Board's committee may ask a psychologist for a letter of reflection. Have your adviser read it, keep it with the letter of counsel, and add the dated evidence of each change.
Can I complete a course before the counselling starts?
Yes. A course from this site is not a replacement for counselling the authority arranges or for anything a letter of counsel asks of you. Completing one on the area of concern gives you the standards to discuss in counselling and material for your reflection. Keep the dated certificate with your remediation plan, and refer to it in any reply the letter asks for, through your indemnity insurer or professional association.
