Topic hub · Professional boundaries · Every Council and Board
Professional Boundaries and Ethical Boundaries: a Hub for New Zealand Health Practitioners
In short
Professional boundaries keep the relationship with a patient or a colleague a professional one. A boundary crossing can be harmless and explained; a boundaries violation harms the patient or serves the practitioner’s own needs. Sexual misconduct, unwanted touch, dual relationships, gifts, social media contact and harassment are the areas where a boundaries breach reaches a Council or Board. This hub brings together our guides and CPD courses on each of them.
This hub is for any practitioner registered with a responsible authority under the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003: if a concern about boundaries has been raised with your Council or Board or the Health and Disability Commissioner, if your employer has raised one, or if you are choosing CPD on boundaries for recertification. Each section explains one part of the topic in plain words and links to the guide or course that covers it in depth.
At a glance
- Professional boundaries and ethical boundaries apply to every relationship with a patient or a colleague.
- A boundary crossing can be harmless; a boundaries violation harms the patient or the relationship.
- Every patient has the right to be free from sexual, financial or other exploitation under the Code of Rights.
- Consent, privacy and the offer of a support person or chaperone protect the patient during a sensitive examination.
- After a boundaries breach, a Council or Board looks for insight, reflection and remediation, not only an apology.
Professional boundaries and ethical boundaries
A health practitioner holds knowledge, access to private information and, at times, physical closeness to a person who is unwell, worried or dependent. Professional boundaries are the limits that keep that relationship centred on the patient’s needs. They apply in a clinic, on a ward, in a patient’s home, in the community and online.
Ethical boundaries describe the same limits from the side of values. They ask whose need an action meets: the patient’s or your own. A practitioner who lends money to a patient, treats a close friend, or uses a patient’s contacts for business may not break a written rule in every case, but has crossed an ethical boundary, and the Council or Board will ask why.
Every responsible authority’s code of conduct or code of ethics covers boundaries. The Medical Council has a statement on sexual boundaries in the doctor–patient relationship, and the Nursing Council has guidelines on professional boundaries. Our guide a professional boundaries concern to your Council or Board explains how these are applied.
Boundary crossing and boundaries violation
Boundaries are easier to understand as a line with steps along it than as a single wall.
- Boundary crossing. A step outside the usual professional relationship that does no harm and that you can explain, for example a short personal disclosure that helps a patient feel understood, or a small gift accepted under your workplace policy. Record the reason if it could be questioned later.
- Boundaries violation. A step that harms the patient or the relationship, or that meets the practitioner’s own needs: secrecy, special treatment, personal contact outside care, money, or sexual contact. A violation breaches the code of conduct.
- Drift. Small crossings that repeat and grow, such as longer appointments, private messages and meetings outside work, can become a violation without one clear moment of decision. This pattern appears in boundaries concerns.
Our guide boundary crossing vs boundary violation sets the two side by side in a table, with the warning signs.
What counts as a boundaries breach
A breach of professional boundaries can take several forms, with a patient or a colleague:
- Physical boundaries, inappropriate behaviour and unwanted touch. Touch that is not needed for the examination or treatment, that the patient has not agreed to, or that continues after the patient is uncomfortable. Comments about a patient’s body or appearance fall here too.
- Dual relationships. Treating a partner, a relative, a close friend, an employee or a business contact, or starting a personal relationship with a patient. In a small community some overlap cannot be avoided; the question is how you manage it and record it.
- Gifts, money and favours. Gifts beyond a token, loans, being named in a will, or business dealings with a patient. The Financial Integrity course covers this area.
- Social media. Friend requests, private messages and posts that mix the professional and the personal. The Social Media Professionalism and Boundaries course covers this area.
- Cultural safety and respect. Treating a patient differently because of who they are, or care that the patient does not experience as safe. See cultural safety in healthcare in Aotearoa New Zealand.
- Harassment and bullying. Conduct towards a colleague, a student or a staff member that is unwelcome, demeaning or threatening. This is covered under boundaries with a colleague, below.
Sexual boundaries and sexual misconduct
Sexual boundaries are the clearest line in professional practice. A sexual or romantic relationship with a current patient is never acceptable, and the patient’s agreement does not change that, because the power in the relationship sits with the practitioner. Sexual misconduct includes sexual contact, sexualised comments, requests for a date, and examinations that are not clinically needed or are carried out without consent.
A relationship with a former patient is also a risk. The Council or Board looks at the kind of care given, how long ago it ended, how vulnerable the person was, and whether the practitioner used information or trust gained in practice. Right 2 of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights gives every patient the right to be free from sexual, financial or other exploitation.
Our guide sexual boundaries and sexual misconduct covers former patients, sensitive examinations, chaperone conditions and the Tribunal in detail.
Where a concern is of a sexual nature, the authority can suspend you or place conditions on your practice while it is investigated. Our guide on interim suspension and conditions on practice explains how that works.
Sensitive examinations and chaperones
A sensitive or intimate examination needs a clear clinical reason, an explanation in plain words, the patient’s informed consent for that examination, privacy while the patient undresses, and the offer of a support person or a chaperone. Record the offer, the patient’s answer, the name of anyone present, and the findings. Stop if the patient asks you to stop.
Right 7 of the Code of Rights sets out informed consent; see informed consent in New Zealand: Right 7 and what your Council expects. The course Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice covers consent and chaperones together.
Boundaries with a colleague
The codes of conduct expect the same respect towards colleagues, students and staff as towards patients. A boundaries breach with a colleague includes harassment, bullying, sexual comments or advances, a personal relationship with a colleague you supervise or assess, and sharing a colleague’s private information. These concerns reach a Council or Board from colleagues and employers, and they follow the same conduct route as a concern raised by a patient.
The course Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues covers both kinds of relationship.
After a boundaries concern
A concern about care given to a patient goes first to the Health and Disability Commissioner; see an HDC complaint and how it reaches your Council. A concern raised with your Council or Board is a conduct matter: the authority can refer it to a Professional Conduct Committee, which can lay a charge before the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. Our professional misconduct hub explains each step.
At every stage, the Council or Board looks for insight into what went wrong and why, reflection on the effect on the patient or colleague, and remediation: what you have done so that it does not happen again. Read showing insight, reflection and a remediation plan and how to respond to a Council or Board notification.
Guides by Council and Board
Start with the two guides on the core questions:
What happens after a notification or complaint, written for each profession:
Courses
Each course is online, at your own pace, with 2 CPD hours and a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses: NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10). They serve both a complaint or notification and CPD for recertification.
2 CPD hoursProfessional Boundaries Course 2 CPD hoursEthical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues 2 CPD hoursSocial Media Professionalism and Boundaries for Healthcare Professionals 2 CPD hoursPrivacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice 2 CPD hoursEnsuring Dignity and Non-Discrimination for Healthcare ProfessionalsQuestions and answers
What are professional boundaries in healthcare?
Professional boundaries are the limits that keep the relationship between a health practitioner and a patient or a colleague a professional one. They protect the person with less power in the relationship and the trust the public places in the profession. Keeping them is the practitioner’s responsibility, even where the other person wanted the contact.
What are ethical boundaries?
Ethical boundaries are the same limits seen from the side of values: honesty, respect, fairness and putting the patient’s interests before your own. A practitioner can stay inside the written rules and still cross an ethical boundary, for example by using a patient’s trust for personal gain.
What is the difference between a boundary crossing and a boundary violation?
A boundary crossing is a step outside the usual professional relationship that does no harm and can be explained, such as a short personal disclosure that helps the patient. A boundaries violation is a step that harms the patient or the relationship, or that serves the practitioner’s own needs. Repeated crossings can become a violation.
What counts as a breach of professional boundaries?
A boundaries breach includes a sexual or romantic relationship with a patient, sexualised comments or touch, unwanted or unnecessary physical contact, dual relationships that harm the care given, gifts or money beyond a token, personal contact on social media, and bullying or harassment of a colleague.
Is sexual misconduct always a boundaries breach?
Yes. A sexual relationship with a current patient is never acceptable, whatever the patient says they want. The Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights gives every patient the right to be free from sexual, financial or other exploitation, and a sexual boundary concern can lead to interim suspension and a charge before the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal.
Do professional boundaries apply to colleagues?
Yes. The codes of conduct expect respectful relationships with colleagues, students and staff. Harassment, bullying, sexual comments, and using a senior role to pressure a junior colleague are boundary breaches with a colleague, and they can reach your Council or Board.
What happens after a boundaries concern reaches my Council or Board?
The responsible authority writes to you with the concern and asks for your response. A boundary concern is a conduct matter: the authority can refer it to a Professional Conduct Committee, which can lay a charge before the Tribunal. While a Committee investigates, the authority can suspend you or place conditions on your practice if it considers that necessary to protect the public.
Which course should I take after a boundaries concern?
Start with the course that matches the concern raised: the Professional Boundaries Course for a concern with a patient, Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues for a concern that involves a colleague, and Social Media Professionalism and Boundaries for an online concern. Each course is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10), with 2 CPD hours and a certificate. The same courses count as CPD for recertification.
Sources and further reading
The regulator’s own documents this page is written from. Read them alongside it; they are the standard a Board applies.
- Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2003/0048/latest/DLM203312.html
- Health and Disability Commissioner — Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rightshttps://www.hdc.org.nz/your-rights/about-the-code/code-of-health-and-disability-services-consumers-rights/
- Nursing Council of New Zealand — Guidelines: Professional boundarieshttps://www.nursingcouncil.org.nz/common/Uploaded%20files/Public/Nursing/Code%20of%20Conduct/Guidelines%20Prof%20Boundaries%20Booklet%20full.pdf
- Medical Council of New Zealand — Current standardshttps://www.mcnz.org.nz/our-standards/current-standards/
- Manatū Hauora — Responsible authoritieshttps://www.health.govt.nz/regulation-legislation/health-practitioners/responsible-authorities
This page is general information. It is not legal advice and does not create a practitioner–adviser relationship. If you have received a notification or a complaint, seek advice from your indemnity insurer, your union or professional association, or a lawyer who acts in health practitioner matters. Healthcare Ethics Courses is an independent provider of remediation courses and is independent and not affiliated with any Council, Board, the Health and Disability Commissioner or the Tribunal; their names are used for reference only.
