
Informed consent in New Zealand is a legal right, set out in Right 7 of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights. Right 7(1) says services may be provided to a consumer "only if that consumer makes an informed choice and gives informed consent", unless a law or another provision of the Code says otherwise. The consent rests on two other rights: Right 6, the right to be fully informed, and Right 5, the right to effective communication, including a competent interpreter where needed. Consent must be in writing in four situations, and a patient can refuse or withdraw consent at any time. A consent concern can reach you as a Health and Disability Commissioner complaint, a Council or Board notification, or both.
This guide sets out what Right 7 says, what information a patient is entitled to, when consent must be written, what your Council or Board expects, and what to do if a consent concern has been raised. If one has, our Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice course (NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10), 2 CPD hours) is written for that situation.
What Right 7 says
Right 7 is headed "Right to make an informed choice and give informed consent". Its ten parts, in plain words:
- Consent first. A service may be provided only if the consumer makes an informed choice and gives informed consent, except where an enactment, the common law or another provision of the Code says otherwise (Right 7(1)).
- Competence is presumed. Every consumer "must be presumed competent" to make an informed choice and give informed consent, "unless there are reasonable grounds for believing that the consumer is not competent" (Right 7(2)).
- Diminished competence. A consumer with diminished competence keeps the right to make informed choices and give consent "to the extent appropriate to his or her level of competence" (Right 7(3)).
- When a consumer is not competent. If no one entitled to consent on the consumer's behalf is available, you may provide services only where it is in the consumer's best interests, you have taken reasonable steps to find out the consumer's views, and you either act consistently with the choice they would make if competent or, if their views are not known, take into account the views of other suitable people interested in their welfare (Right 7(4)).
- Written consent. Where consent to a procedure is required, it must be in writing in the four situations listed below (Right 7(6)).
- Refusal and withdrawal. Every consumer has the right to refuse services and to withdraw consent (Right 7(7)).
- Preference of provider. A consumer may express a preference as to who provides services and have it met where practicable (Right 7(8)).
- Body parts and bodily substances. Rights 7(9) and 7(10) cover the return, disposal, storage and use of tissue removed during a procedure.
The information a patient is entitled to (Right 6)
Consent is only informed if the information was given. Right 6(1) gives every consumer the right to the information "that a reasonable consumer, in that consumer's circumstances, would expect to receive", including:
- an explanation of their condition;
- an explanation of the options available, "including an assessment of the expected risks, side effects, benefits, and costs of each option";
- advice of the estimated time within which services will be provided;
- notice of any proposed participation in teaching or research;
- any other information required by legal, professional, ethical and other relevant standards; and
- the results of tests and procedures.
Right 6(2) is the one tied directly to consent: before making a choice or giving consent, every consumer has the right to the information "a reasonable consumer, in that consumer's circumstances, needs to make an informed choice or give informed consent". The test is what this patient, in their circumstances, would need, not what you would choose to tell them. Right 6(3) adds the right to honest and accurate answers to questions, including about your identity and qualifications, your recommendation and how to get a second opinion, and Right 6(4) the right to a written summary on request.
Right 5 sits underneath both. Communication must be "in a form, language, and manner that enables the consumer to understand the information provided", including a competent interpreter "where necessary and reasonably practicable". Consent given by a patient who did not understand what they were told is not informed consent.
When consent must be in writing
Right 7(6) says that where informed consent to a health care procedure is required, it must be in writing if:
- Research. The consumer is to take part in any research.
- Experimental procedures. The procedure is experimental.
- General anaesthetic. The consumer will be under general anaesthetic.
- Significant risk. There is a significant risk of adverse effects on the consumer.
Outside those four, consent can be verbal or shown by the patient's actions, but the duties in Rights 5, 6 and 7 still apply, and your clinical record is how you show that they were met.
What to write in the clinical record about the consent discussion is set out in recording informed consent.
"Reasonable actions": how the Code is applied to you
Clause 3 of the Code, "Provider compliance", says a provider "is not in breach of this Code if the provider has taken reasonable actions in the circumstances to give effect to the rights, and comply with the duties". It adds that "the onus is on the provider to prove that it took reasonable actions", and that the circumstances include "the consumer's clinical circumstances and the provider's resource constraints".
Two things follow for a practitioner facing a consent complaint. First, the question is not whether the outcome was good, but whether you took reasonable steps to inform the patient and obtain their consent. Second, the burden is on you to show it. Your notes, any written information you gave, an interpreter's involvement and the record of the patient's questions are your evidence.
What your Council or Board expects
Each responsible authority sets standards for its profession under the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003, and consent runs through all of them.
- Doctors. The Medical Council publishes a statement on informed consent (dated 1 June 2021). Its page says the statement "outlines what we expect of doctors when helping patients to make an informed decision about their care and treatment", and that "patients are entitled to information about their health and the care they are receiving".
- Nurses. The Nursing Council's Code of Conduct "tells the public what they can expect of a nurse" and, in the Council's words, "provides a yardstick for evaluating the conduct of nurses". It is framed around four core values, respect, trust, partnership and integrity, and eight principles. Our guide to the Nursing Council Code of Conduct explains how a notification is measured against it.
- Other professions. Your own Council or Board's code of conduct and standards set out its expectations on consent. Read the current version on its website before you respond to a concern.
Where language or culture affects how information is given and understood, read our guide to cultural safety in healthcare in Aotearoa New Zealand alongside Right 5.
How a consent concern reaches you
Right 10 of the Code gives every consumer the right to complain about a provider, including to the Health and Disability Commissioner. A consent complaint can therefore start with the HDC, with your Council or Board, or with your employer, and can move between them. Our guides explain each route: an HDC complaint and how it reaches your Council, an HDC breach finding and the Director of Proceedings, and the Council or Board investigation process.
What to do if a consent concern has been raised
- Speak to your indemnity insurer or professional association first. Do this before you put anything in writing to the HDC, your Council or Board, or your employer.
- Read the clinical record as it stands. Note what it shows about the options, risks, questions and the patient's decision. Do not alter it.
- Write your own account while you remember it, with dates: what you explained, how, whether an interpreter or support person was there, and what the patient asked.
- Answer the concern against the Code. Address Rights 5, 6 and 7 directly: what information you gave, how you checked understanding, and how consent was given or recorded.
- Show insight and what has changed. Say what you would do differently and what you have already changed, such as a consent discussion template, written information for patients, or using interpreters. A course on consent, with a dated certificate and a written reflection, is evidence you can put in your response or remediation plan.
Where remediation courses fit
Our courses are remediation courses for a concern raised with the HDC or your Council or Board, and you can also record the hours as professional development where your Council or Board counts them. For a consent concern, Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice covers consent, privacy and the presence of another person during an examination. Effective Communication for Healthcare Professionals fits a concern about how information was explained, and the Medical Ethics Course covers consent and capacity and decisions involving whānau. For any profession, see remediation courses by Council or Board.
Sources and further reading
- Health and Disability Commissioner: Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights
- Health and Disability Commissioner: The Code and your rights
- Medical Council of New Zealand: Informed consent
- Nursing Council of New Zealand: Code of Conduct
This guide is part of our Professional Boundaries hub. See also the Professional Misconduct hub.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a Council or Board complaint about consent and chaperone? Our consent and chaperone course is written for health practitioners and follows your Council or Board's code of conduct; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my Council or Board investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which a Professional Conduct Committee and your Council or Board look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Council, Board or Health and Disability Commissioner — or before a Professional Conduct Committee, the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal or a competence review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
What is informed consent in New Zealand?
It is the right in Right 7 of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights: a service may be provided only if the consumer makes an informed choice and gives informed consent, unless a law or another provision of the Code says otherwise. It depends on Right 6, the right to be fully informed, and Right 5, the right to effective communication, including a competent interpreter where needed.
What is Right 7 of the Code of Rights?
Right 7 is the right to make an informed choice and give informed consent. It presumes every consumer is competent unless there are reasonable grounds to believe otherwise, protects consumers with diminished competence, sets the rules where a consumer is not competent, requires written consent in four situations, and gives every consumer the right to refuse services and to withdraw consent.
When does consent have to be in writing in New Zealand?
Right 7(6) requires written consent, where consent to a health care procedure is required, if the consumer is to take part in research, the procedure is experimental, the consumer will be under general anaesthetic, or there is a significant risk of adverse effects. In other situations consent can be verbal, but the duties to inform and to communicate effectively still apply.
What information must I give a patient before they consent?
Right 6(2) entitles the consumer to the information a reasonable consumer, in their circumstances, needs to make an informed choice. Right 6(1) lists an explanation of their condition, the options with the expected risks, side effects, benefits and costs of each, the estimated time for the service, and any information required by legal, professional and ethical standards.
What should I do if a patient complains that I did not get informed consent?
Speak to your indemnity insurer or professional association before you write to anyone. Read the record as it stands without altering it, write your own dated account, and answer the concern against Rights 5, 6 and 7. Show insight and what you have changed, such as how you now record consent discussions; a course on consent with a written reflection is evidence you can include.
This article is published by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnity insurer, professional association or a lawyer about your own matter.
