
When a consent complaint reaches the Health and Disability Commissioner or a Council or Board, the first thing read is the record of the consent discussion. For healthcare professionals in New Zealand, the record has to show what was discussed, the risks raised, the patient's questions and the decision, not only that a form was signed. This guide sets out what to write, when written consent is required, how to record a refusal and the gaps that weaken a record.
If a consent concern has been raised, Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, self-paced, with a dated certificate on completion.
What should you record about informed consent?
The Medical Council's statement on informed consent (June 2021) asks doctors to keep clear and accurate records that note the information discussed, any specific risks highlighted, any requests or concerns the patient expressed, and the decisions made with the reasons for them. It asks for enough detail to give an accurate summary of the discussion, and enough for another practitioner to follow. Its statement on managing patient records (December 2020) lists, among what a record must contain, the information given and options discussed, decisions and their reasons, the consent given, and requests or concerns raised during the consultation.
The same points serve any practitioner. A consent note that will stand up later covers:
- The patient's situation: what they were told about their condition and why the treatment was proposed.
- The options: each option discussed, including no treatment, and the expected benefits of each.
- The risks: the specific risks discussed, in the words you used, and any risk that matters to this patient because of their circumstances.
- Questions and concerns: what the patient asked and what you answered.
- Written information given: any leaflet or resource, by name or version.
- Support and communication: who was present, and any interpreter used.
- The decision: what the patient chose, and their reasons where they gave them.
- Date, time and your name, written as soon as practicable after the discussion.
The Nursing Council's Code of Conduct asks nurses to keep clear and accurate records (standard 4.8), and its guidance on documentation asks for records of the discussions you have, completed as soon as possible after the event, and signed, dated and timed.
When must consent be in writing in New Zealand?
Right 7(6) of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights says that, where informed consent to a health care procedure is required, it must be in writing if:
- the consumer is to take part in any research;
- the procedure is experimental;
- the consumer will be under general anaesthetic; or
- there is a significant risk of adverse effects on the consumer.
Outside those four cases, consent can be given orally, and the clinical note is the evidence of it. The wider rules of Right 7 are explained in our guide to informed consent and Right 7.
Is a signed consent form enough?
No. The Medical Council says consent is more than signing forms and completing paperwork. In HDC decision 19HDC01255 (2023), a signed form stated that alternatives had been discussed, but there was no record of the content of the consent discussion, and the decision reminded the provider to document the specifics of consent discussions clearly. A form records that the patient agreed. The note records what they agreed to and what they were told.
How do you record a refusal or a withdrawal of consent?
Right 7(7) gives every consumer the right to refuse services and to withdraw consent. Record the refusal as fully as a consent: what was offered, the risks of not going ahead that you explained, the patient's reasons if they gave them, any other option offered, and the follow-up agreed. The Medical Council also asks that, where a patient does not want information, you record that decision and the reasons the patient gives.
What gaps weaken a consent record?
- A form with no clinical note of the discussion behind it.
- Generic wording such as "risks explained" with no risks named.
- No record of the options, including no treatment.
- A note written days later, or added after a complaint. Never change an existing entry; add a dated late entry if something was missed.
- No record of the patient's questions, or of an interpreter.
Record-keeping concerns in general are covered in clinical records concerns, and where another person was present in the room, see chaperones.
Where remediation and CPD fit
If a consent complaint has been made, a remediation plan can show how you now record consent, with an example of your new note format. Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice covers the consent discussion, and Documentation for Healthcare Professionals covers the record. Without a complaint, each gives 2 CPD hours with a dated certificate for your CPD record. Each is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10).
Sources and further reading
- Health and Disability Commissioner: Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights: Right 7.
- Medical Council of New Zealand: informed consent (June 2021).
- Medical Council of New Zealand: managing patient records (December 2020).
- Nursing Council of New Zealand: Code of Conduct: standard 4.8 and the guidance on documentation.
- Health and Disability Commissioner: decision 19HDC01255.
This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a Council or Board complaint about consent and chaperone? Our consent and chaperone course is written for health practitioners and follows your Council or Board's code of conduct; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my Council or Board investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which a Professional Conduct Committee and your Council or Board look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Council, Board or Health and Disability Commissioner — or before a Professional Conduct Committee, the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal or a competence review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
What should I record about informed consent?
Healthcare professionals in New Zealand should record the information and options discussed, the specific risks raised, the patient's questions and concerns, any written information given, and the decision with its reasons, dated and signed as soon as practicable.
Is a signed consent form enough?
No. The Medical Council says consent is more than signing forms, and the HDC has criticised providers whose signed form was not backed by a note of the discussion. Healthcare professionals in New Zealand should record what was discussed as well as the signature.
When is written consent required in New Zealand?
Under Right 7(6) of the Code of Rights, healthcare professionals in New Zealand must obtain written consent where the patient will take part in research, the procedure is experimental, the patient will be under general anaesthetic, or there is a significant risk of adverse effects.
How detailed should consent notes be?
Detailed enough to give an accurate summary of the discussion and for another practitioner to follow it. For healthcare professionals in New Zealand, that means naming the risks and options discussed, not writing only "risks explained".
Is there a course on consent for a complaint or CPD?
Yes. Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, self-paced, with a dated certificate for a remediation plan after a complaint or notification, or for the CPD record of healthcare professionals in New Zealand.
