
No. A probity course is not enough on its own for an honesty concern, because the Council and the Tribunal judge honesty by what you have said and done, and a certificate is one dated part of that. For pharmacists in New Zealand, the Pharmacy Council NZ probity course is worth taking because it shows you how to build the rest: an accurate account, records left as they stand, and changes with dates.
Why a certificate alone does not answer an honesty concern
An honesty concern asks whether the Council can rely on what you say now. A course shows you have engaged with the standard; the rest comes from what you send with it:
- An account that matches the record. Each fact checked against the record, with references.
- A correction, where one is owed. If an earlier account to the Council, an auditor or your employer was not accurate, say so, plainly, after advice.
- Existing entries left as they are. No altered figure, no replaced form and no back-dated entry once a concern has been raised; any correction is a new dated note that shows the change.
- Changes that can be checked. A revised reconciliation process or an audit with results, dated.
In decision Phar21/533P, the Tribunal said the pharmacist had not shown any insight in the four years since disclosure, and that his statements about not making the "mistake" again were not enough. The guide to showing insight and building a remediation plan sets out how the pieces fit together.
What the Code of Ethics 2018 says about honesty
Principle 4 of the Code reads: a pharmacist acts with honesty and integrity and maintains public trust and confidence in the profession. The standards that an honesty concern engages are:
- 4C: accurate, truthful, relevant and independent information that is not misleading to patients, the public or other health professionals;
- 4D: no abuse of your professional position;
- 4E: respond honestly, openly, courteously and promptly to complaints and criticism;
- 5C: fulfil all legal obligations;
- 7E: avoid conduct that might bring the profession into disrepute.
The guide to an honesty or probity concern covers how every authority reads one.
Why a cover-up is treated as more serious than the first error
In 1236/Phar21/514D, the wrong medicine was dispensed and the patient was later admitted to hospital. The Tribunal accepted that the error was negligent but was reluctant to treat it alone as serious enough for discipline. What followed was different: the pharmacist replaced the prescription form with backdated copies, forged two staff members' initials and told others that a colleague had made the error. That was found to be malpractice, and registration was cancelled.
A false account can be answered without cancellation where the facts allow. In Phar25/633P, an intern who gave a false name to a Medsafe auditor was censured, ordered to complete a six-month mentoring programme with monthly practice reviews, required to disclose the decision to employers for 18 months, and ordered to pay part of the costs. The Tribunal's options are set out in decision Phar21/533P: cancellation, suspension for up to three years, conditions, censure, a fine of up to $30,000, and costs. It said there that neither cancellation nor suspension is meant to punish, but to protect the public.
How an honesty concern reaches the Pharmacy Council
- A conviction. Section 67 of the HPCA Act requires a court to notify the Council of a conviction for an offence punishable by imprisonment for 3 months or longer.
- A colleague, an employer or an auditor. A concern about records, claims or stock can come to the Council directly, as the staff member's complaint did in 514D.
- The Health and Disability Commissioner. Where a patient was affected, section 64 requires the Council to pass the complaint to the Commissioner.
The Council asks for your written submission before it considers the complaint and can refer a conduct concern to a Professional Conduct Committee under section 68. Under section 69 it can suspend or place conditions on your practice while a criminal proceeding or investigation is pending, after telling you its reasons. The guide to what happens after a Pharmacy Council complaint sets out each stage.
What the probity course covers
Ten sections and a final assessment. It defines probity as honesty, integrity and transparency, sets out how the Pharmacy Council and the other authorities view it, and covers records, claims, conflicts of interest and candour. It compares weak and strong responses, uses case studies (one on falsified pharmacy records), and ends with remediation through audits and supervision and how to present honesty at a hearing.
When another course fits better
If the concern is that you were slow to tell a patient about an error, the Pharmacy Council NZ candour course is closer to it. If it is about claims to a funder or stock and money, the Pharmacy Council NZ financial integrity course fits better.
Counting it as MyRecert CPD
The course can be your keeping-up-to-date activity for the year. Your one critical reflection can be on the incident behind the concern. The guide to pharmacist recertification and MyRecert covers each requirement.
Sources and further reading
- Pharmacy Council: Code of Ethics 2018: Principle 4 and standards 4C, 4D, 4E, 5C and 7E.
- Health and Disability Commissioner: Tribunal case note 1236/Phar21/514D: a dispensing error followed by altered records.
- Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal: decision Phar21/533P: the penalty options, insight and the purpose of a penalty.
- Pharmacy Council: Tribunal summary Phar25/633P: a false name given to an auditor and the penalty.
- Pharmacy Council: A complaint has been made against me: written submissions and the Professional Conduct Committee.
- Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003: sections 64, 67, 68 and 69.
- Pharmacy Council: MyRecert requirements: critical reflection and keeping up to date.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a Council or Board complaint about probity and honesty? Our probity and honesty course is written for pharmacists and follows the Pharmacy Council's Code of Ethics; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my Council or Board investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which a Professional Conduct Committee and Pharmacy Council NZ look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Council, Board or Health and Disability Commissioner — or before a Professional Conduct Committee, the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal or a competence review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a probity course for pharmacists in New Zealand?
Yes. Probity and Honesty for Healthcare Professionals is an online remediation and CPD course that pharmacists in New Zealand can use after an honesty concern, with a section on how the Pharmacy Council views probity. It is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10), takes 2 CPD hours at your own pace and ends with a dated certificate.
Can a pharmacist keep their registration after an honesty finding?
It depends on the facts. In Phar25/633P, an intern who gave a false name to an auditor was censured and ordered to complete a mentoring programme and to disclose the decision to employers for 18 months. In 1236/Phar21/514D, altered records and blaming a colleague after an error led to cancellation.
Does the probity course count for MyRecert?
Yes, as CPD you choose. It can be logged as your keeping-up-to-date activity, and an incident in your practice can be the subject of your one critical reflection for the year.
Should I correct an earlier account I gave the Council?
If it was not accurate, take advice from your indemnity insurer or a lawyer and then correct it in writing, in your own words. Standard 4E of the Code asks you to respond honestly and openly to complaints. A correction made before it is found says more about your honesty now than any certificate.
Will a conviction reach the Pharmacy Council?
Yes, for the offences the Act names. Section 67 of the HPCA Act requires a court to notify the Council of a conviction for an offence punishable by imprisonment for 3 months or longer, among others. The Council can then refer the matter to a Professional Conduct Committee, which can lay a charge before the Tribunal.
