Council or Board notificationCompetence reviewsProfessional Conduct CommitteesRemediation coursesDoctorsNursesMidwivesDentistsPharmacistsAll Health Practitioners
Skip to content

The process

The Four Pillars of Medical Ethics, Applied to a Complaint

Written and reviewed by , MBBS, MRCS, MRCGP, Postgraduate Certificate in Healthcare Law and Ethics Published 29 October 2026 13 min read

In short

The four pillars of medical ethics are autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. A complaint in New Zealand is written in a different language: the Health and Disability Commissioner and your Council ask whether you complied with a right in the Code of Rights, such as Right 7 on consent, or met the standard your Council expects. Map each pillar to that right or standard in your response. Each CPD course is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours.

The Four Pillars of Medical Ethics, Applied to a Complaint

The four pillars of medical ethics are autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. They are taught in every health programme, and they are the frame on which ethics teaching in New Zealand is built. What is taught less is that a complaint is written in a different language. The Health and Disability Commissioner, the Medical Council, the Nursing Council and the other responsible authorities do not ask whether you respected autonomy; they ask whether you complied with Right 7 of the Code of Rights, or met the standard your Council expects. This guide maps each pillar to the rights and standards it lives in, works three complaints through the pillars, and shows how to use the four as the structure of a written response and of a reflection you can record as professional development.

If a complaint or notification has been made about you, the course written for this is the Medical Ethics Course, which applies the four pillars to the HDC Code and to your Council's or Board's standards, with Reflection for Fitness to Practise for the written reflection. Each is NZ$200 (NZ$140 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, with a dated certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses that you can put in your response and record as professional development.

The four pillars in one table

The pillars come from Beauchamp and Childress's Principles of Biomedical Ethics. They are principles, not rules: each describes a duty, and the work of ethics is weighing them when they pull in different directions. The right-hand column is where each one sits in the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights, which the HDC's page describes as establishing "the rights of consumers, and the obligations and duties of providers to comply with the Code".

PillarThe dutyWhere it sits in the HDC Code
AutonomyRespect the patient's right to decide what happens to them, with the information they need to decide.Right 6, the right to be fully informed; Right 7, the right to make an informed choice and give informed consent, including the right "to refuse services and to withdraw consent to services" (Right 7(7)).
BeneficenceAct for the patient's good: assess, treat, refer, follow up.Right 4(1), services "provided with reasonable care and skill"; Right 4(3), "in a manner consistent with his or her needs"; Right 4(5), co-operation among providers "to ensure quality and continuity of services".
Non-maleficenceDo no harm; weigh the harm a treatment can do against its benefit.Right 4(4), services provided "in a manner that minimises the potential harm to, and optimises the quality of life of, that consumer"; Right 4(2), compliance with "legal, professional, ethical, and other relevant standards".
JusticeTreat patients fairly; do not let who they are change the care they get; use shared resources fairly.Right 1, respect, privacy and services that "take into account the needs, values, and beliefs of different cultural, religious, social, and ethnic groups, including the needs, values, and beliefs of Māori"; Right 2, freedom "from discrimination, coercion, harassment, and sexual, financial or other exploitation"; Right 3, dignity and independence.

The Medical Council's own statement of good medical practice puts the first three in one sentence: "A doctor's first concern is to take care of their patient, and to do so with respect, honesty and professionalism." Every other responsible authority says the same thing in its code of conduct in its own words. The pillars are the grammar underneath.

Why the mapping matters when a complaint is made

A complaint reaches you as a letter from the HDC, your Council or Board, or a Professional Conduct Committee, and it is framed in their terms. The Medical Council's conduct and competence page explains that a notification can come from colleagues, employers, the Ministry of Health, ACC or "patients by way of the HDC", that the information in the referral "will be given to the doctor so they can respond", and that the Notifications Triage Team then decides whether no further action is needed, whether further education on a specific issue is enough, whether the matter goes to a full Council meeting, or whether it is referred to a PCC. The question at every one of those steps is whether a right or a standard was met.

So the first use of the pillars is to read the complaint. Each pillar tells you which rights to go to, and each right tells you what the Code required of you. Clause 3 of the Code then tells you what you are answering: "A provider is not in breach of this Code if the provider has taken reasonable actions in the circumstances to give effect to the rights", and "the onus is on the provider to prove that it took reasonable actions", where the circumstances include "the consumer's clinical circumstances and the provider's resource constraints". A response that shows the reasonable actions you took, right by right, is a response written to the test that will be applied to it. Our guide on how an HDC complaint reaches your Council covers the route; this guide covers the content.

Three complaints, worked through the pillars

The three cases below are invented. Each is the kind of complaint a New Zealand practitioner can receive, and each is read first through the pillars and then through the Code.

1. "Nobody told me there was another option" (autonomy)

The pillar is autonomy: the patient's right to decide depends on knowing what the choices were. The rights are Right 6(1)(b), "an explanation of the options available, including an assessment of the expected risks, side effects, benefits, and costs of each option", and Right 7(1), that services may be provided "only if that consumer makes an informed choice and gives informed consent". What the response has to show is what you explained, what the record says you explained, and whether a reasonable consumer in that patient's circumstances would have expected to hear about the other option. If the option was not mentioned, the response says so, explains why, and sets out what has changed: a written options sheet, a consent conversation that is documented at the time, a second appointment before a decision for elective procedures. Our guide to informed consent and Right 7 goes through the consent standard in detail.

2. "The dose was wrong and no one checked" (beneficence and non-maleficence)

The pillars are beneficence (the duty to treat well) and non-maleficence (the duty not to harm), and this is the kind of complaint where the two are tested together. The rights are Right 4(1), reasonable care and skill; Right 4(2), compliance with professional standards, which here means the medicines policy and the prescribing and administration standards of your profession; Right 4(4), minimising potential harm; and Right 4(5), co-operation among providers, because the check that should have caught the error is a shared duty. What the response has to show is the sequence of events as the record has them, what you did once the error was found (the patient's care, the disclosure to the patient and family, the incident report), the cause as you now understand it, and the change. Clause 3's reference to "resource constraints" is relevant if the ward was short-staffed, but it explains the circumstances; it does not replace the reasonable actions you took within them. For the reflection that goes with a response like this, see our guide on reflective practice with a worked example, which uses a medication error.

3. "I was treated differently because of who I am" (justice)

The pillar is justice: the same care, with the same respect, whoever the patient is. The rights are Right 1(1) and 1(3), respect and services that take into account "the needs, values, and beliefs of different cultural, religious, social, and ethnic groups, including the needs, values, and beliefs of Māori"; Right 2, freedom from discrimination; Right 3, dignity; Right 5, effective communication in a form the consumer can understand; and Right 8, the right to have "one or more support persons of his or her choice present, except where safety may be compromised or another consumer's rights may be unreasonably infringed". What the response has to show is harder than in the first two cases, because the complaint is about how the care felt, and the record will say little. The response sets out what happened from your side without arguing with the patient's experience of it, addresses each right (why the support person was asked to leave, and whether Right 8's exception applied), and shows what you have done since: cultural safety training recorded as professional development, a change in how support people are handled, a reflection on the interaction. Our guide to cultural safety in Aotearoa New Zealand explains what each Council expects here.

When the pillars conflict

The pillars earn their place when they disagree, and the Code has already settled some of the arguments. Autonomy against beneficence is the first: a competent patient refuses the treatment you believe they need. Right 7(7) gives the answer: the right "to refuse services and to withdraw consent". The practitioner's duty is to make sure the refusal is informed (Right 6) and to record it, not to override it. Beneficence against non-maleficence is the second: a treatment that can help can also harm. Right 4(4) asks for both in one sentence, minimising harm and optimising quality of life, and Right 6(1)(b) requires the risks and benefits to be explained so that the weighing is the patient's as well as yours. Justice against beneficence is the third: the patient in front of you against the patients waiting. Clause 3 of the Code names "the provider's resource constraints" as part of the circumstances, which means a decision made fairly within real limits is defensible if the record shows the limits and the reasoning.

In a response, naming the conflict is a sign of insight. A sentence such as "I weighed the patient's refusal against my concern for their safety, and I now see that I did not give them the information Right 6 required before I accepted it" tells the reader more than any amount of description.

Using the four pillars as the structure of a response

The reader of your response, whether at the HDC, your Council or Board, or a PCC, is looking for four things: the facts, the rights or standards engaged, your insight, and what has changed. The pillars give you the second of those, and the structure for the rest:

  1. Read the complaint and name the rights. For each concern, write down the pillar and then the right or standard it engages. Do this before you write anything else; it decides what you must answer.
  2. For each right, set out the reasonable actions you took. Clause 3 of the Code puts the onus on you. Facts from the record, in order, with dates.
  3. Where the action fell short, say so. A response that accepts what the record shows, and explains why it happened without excusing it, reads as insight. A response that argues every point reads as its absence.
  4. For each shortfall, the change. What you now do differently, and the evidence: a dated certificate, a changed template, a supervision arrangement, a reflection.
  5. Close with the pillar in your own words. One sentence on what the complaint taught you about respecting choice, acting for the patient, avoiding harm or treating people fairly. That sentence is what the reader remembers.

Our guide on showing insight, reflection and a remediation plan covers what the Councils and Boards read a response for, and the Professional Conduct Committee process explains what happens if the matter goes further.

The four pillars as professional development

Every responsible authority under the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003 requires professional development for an annual practising certificate, and ethics is accepted as a subject for it. Working the pillars through your own practice, against the Code and your Council's or Board's standards, is professional development whether or not a complaint has been made, and a dated certificate from a course that does this can be recorded. If a complaint has been made, the same certificate goes in the response. Our guide to CPD points and hours in New Zealand sets out what each Council asks for.

Which courses fit

For the pillars themselves, applied to the HDC Code and to your Council's or Board's standards, the Medical Ethics Course. For an autonomy complaint, Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice. For a beneficence or non-maleficence complaint, Ensuring Clinical Competence and Patient Safety and, if the harm was not disclosed at the time, Open Disclosure and Duty of Candour. For a justice complaint, Ensuring Dignity and Non-Discrimination. For the written response and reflection, Reflection for Fitness to Practise and Insight for Fitness to Practise.

For a doctor answering a complaint, our guide on why a Medical Council NZ ethics course matters when you face a complaint explains where a dated ethics certificate and a reflection fit in the Council’s process.

For a medical laboratory scientist, the guide to the Medical Sciences Council NZ ethics course after a complaint applies the same questions to laboratory work.

For a medical radiation technologist, the guide to what the Medical Radiation Technologists Board expects from an ethics course sets these questions against the Board's Code of Ethical Conduct.

Sources and further reading

Key Takeaways

  • Which course should I take for a Council or Board complaint about medical ethics? Our medical ethics course is written for health practitioners and follows your Council or Board's code of conduct; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
  • Will a course help my Council or Board investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which a Professional Conduct Committee and your Council or Board look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
  • When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Council, Board or Health and Disability Commissioner — or before a Professional Conduct Committee, the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal or a competence review if the matter has gone further.
  • Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.

Frequently asked questions

What are the four pillars of medical ethics?

Autonomy (respect for the patient's right to decide), beneficence (acting for the patient's good), non-maleficence (avoiding harm) and justice (fairness in how patients are treated and resources are used). The four were set out by Beauchamp and Childress and are used across healthcare, not only in medicine. In New Zealand each has a counterpart in the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers' Rights, which is the standard a complaint is measured against.

How do the four pillars map to the HDC Code of Rights?

Autonomy sits in Right 6 (the right to be fully informed) and Right 7 (the right to make an informed choice and give informed consent, including the right to refuse and withdraw consent). Beneficence and non-maleficence sit in Right 4 (services of an appropriate standard: reasonable care and skill, consistent with the consumer's needs, provided in a manner that minimises potential harm and optimises quality of life). Justice sits in Right 1 (respect, including the needs, values and beliefs of different groups and of Māori), Right 2 (freedom from discrimination, coercion, harassment and exploitation) and Right 3 (dignity and independence).

Which pillar do complaints in New Zealand turn on?

A complaint is written in the Code's language, not the pillars', so the question is which rights it names. A complaint that you did not explain the options or went ahead without agreement is an autonomy complaint under Rights 6 and 7. A complaint about a missed diagnosis, a medication error or a delay is a beneficence and non-maleficence complaint under Right 4. A complaint that you treated someone with less respect or care because of who they are is a justice complaint under Rights 1 to 3. One complaint can raise more than one; reading it this way tells you what to answer.

Can I use the four pillars in my written response to a complaint?

Yes, as the structure, not the vocabulary. The HDC, a Council, a Board or a Professional Conduct Committee reads a response for the facts, the rights or standards engaged, your insight into what fell short and what you have changed. Setting out, under each right the complaint engages, what you did, what the Code required and what you now do differently covers the pillars without naming them. Our course Reflection for Fitness to Practise works through that structure.

Do the four pillars count as professional development?

Working through them against your own practice does. Every responsible authority under the HPCA Act requires professional development for recertification, and ethics is a recognised subject for it. A course that applies the pillars to the HDC Code and to your Council's or Board's standards, with a dated certificate, can be recorded as CPD whether or not a complaint has been made.

What is the difference between beneficence and non-maleficence?

Beneficence is the positive duty to act for the patient's benefit: to assess, treat, refer and follow up. Non-maleficence is the duty not to cause harm, and to weigh the harm a treatment can do against its benefit. Right 4(4) of the Code joins them in one sentence: services must be provided in a manner that minimises the potential harm to, and optimises the quality of life of, the consumer. A complaint about care is tested against both at once.

This article is published by Healthcare Ethics New Zealand for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnity insurer, professional association or a lawyer about your own matter.

‹ All guides

Basket 0 Total NZ$0 View basket
CPD CoursesBulk Buy OfferFrom NZ$140 a course(Bulk Buy of 10)Save up toNZ$600